11 Comments
User's avatar
Patrick Taggart's avatar

Apologies for posting this here. I find Substack confusing and haven't figured out how to send you a personal message; maybe I need to be a paid subscriber to do that.

I wanted to thank you for introducing me to the word "velleity" (used in reference to Hoyle in "The This"). It's such a great word!

When my partner's daughter moans about life with us, and claims to be desperate to move out, but never bothers to look for better paid work, I think: velleity, velleity, all is velleity. (Deep down, I know it's not easy finding one's way as a young person today. )

Expand full comment
Mark Stay's avatar

Robert Rankin tells a story about seeing this at the Tate, leaning forward to admire it more closely, then suddenly drawing back and accidentally headbutting the actor John Hurt who was stood right behind him.

Expand full comment
Adam Roberts's avatar

The Rankin Feller's (War) Doctor strike.

Expand full comment
Patrick Taggart's avatar

Was Hurt hurt? Sorry 😞.

Expand full comment
Mark Stay's avatar

Let’s put it like this… he did the Elephant Man immediately after…

Expand full comment
Drew Milne's avatar

Here's a link to the Fitzwilliam version: https://collection.beta.fitz.ms/id/object/10158

Expand full comment
Drew Milne's avatar

I wrote a paper on this myself some years ago, and tried to track down Dadd's poem that he wrote to go with the picture (also in relation to the other version of this that's in the Fitzwilliam Museum), and the poem, then inaccessible, is now in the public domain: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Elimination_of_a_Picture_%26_its_Subject—called_The_Fellers%27_Master_Stroke

Expand full comment
Marc G's avatar

Interesting read as always. I was startled by how small (about 50x30cm) yet how obsessively detailed the painting is, still unfinished after nine years of one-off work. I'm also reminded of Mark Chadbourn's rather somber novella of the same name (PS, 2002), about a young man's increasing obsession with Dadd and the painting. Dadd is also one of several people haunting David Seabrook's meditation on the weird underbelly of Kent, All the Devils Are Here (Granta, 2002).

Expand full comment
Lev Grossman's avatar

I always make the Dad joke when discussing this painting

Expand full comment
David Perlmutter's avatar

A lot going on here.

Expand full comment
Brian Clegg's avatar

Most importantly, the inspiration for Robert Rankin's The Witches of Chiswick...

Expand full comment